Tasting Notes: Morrissey Fox Blonde Ale

Brewery: Morrissey Fox (or Morissey Fox, or Morrisey Fox… you choose)
Location: Marton cum Grafton, Yorkshire, England
ABV: 4.2%
Version: Bottled
Source: Tesco

Long Intro…

I’m sure everyone is well aware by now that actor Neil Morrissey and chef Richard Fox are currently starring in a TV micro-series – Neil Morrissey’s Risky Business – about the pair’s venture into micro-brewing and pub-owning, the first two episodes of which have aired on Channel 4 recently.

I had no idea that the beer was linked to a TV series when I picked it up in Tesco the other week. I bought it because it was just something new to try and maybe, just a little bit, because I once met Neil Morrissey at a bookstore event that I helped to run back in my book-selling days – he and Martin Clunes were promoting one of their Men Behaving Badly spin-offs and came along to do a live in-character interview and Q&A session, which I seem to remember resulted in a damn good night had by all.

Morrissey Fox Blonde Ale bottleI tried Morrissey Fox Blonde Ale last night and then watched the first episode of the series (courtesy of our Sky+ box) this morning. I thought the most interesting parts of the first episode were the segments in which the two intrepid micro-brewers sat down at a London marketing agency Antidote to discuss an advertising campaign that would catapult their product onto the supermarket shelves. Most probably because I work in marketing myself; beer plus marketing, best of both worlds.

Anyhow, the chap they were talking to (I think it was agency owner and M.D. Tim Ashton) was presented as the voice of sanity and reason amidst the wild, laddish enthusiasm of the other two. And the main point he kept coming back to was a rebuttal to Morrissey Fox’s mission statement – to present themselves as young, enthusiastic, passionate (and media-friendly) micro-brewers and by doing so convert a whole slew of lager drinkers into real ale quaffers instead – which could be summed up quite nicely with a pithy: “so what?”

As in: so, guys, you’ve bought a pub and a micro-brewery and made an initial batch of homebrew and tested it by giving freebies away in Harrogate and folks seemed to like it… but so what? What does Morrissey Fox have to offer that will make the venture stand head-and-shoulders above the hundreds of other micro-breweries with much better brewing credentials, above the 5,000 or so beer varieties currently produced in the UK, and above the huge amount of corporate competition for that all-important, coveted supermarket shelf-space?

To be fair the pair were quick to acknowledge that their main asset in their long run has to be the quality of their beer, the success or failure of which will be the main determinant of the overall success or failure of the entire project, long after the media-buzz (which has to have helped get their bottles on the shelves of Tesco, surely?) has died down again and they’re left with the serious business of actually running a pub and micro-brewery.

So they key question has to be: how does the beer itself shape up against other micro-brew products of a similar ilk? Is it just a case of a gimmick that plays on Morrissey’s celebrity status, or does it have a genuine strength of character that will enable it to stand on its own, without the additional media attention? You know, I’d really like to have been able to voice a resounding “yes!” at this point – if only because the show is very entertaining and I’ve learned quite a bit about brewing, just by watching the first episode and both Morrissey and Fox seem like good blokes and all. The thing is, though…

Actual Tasting Notes…

Morrissey Fox Blonde Ale is a 4.2% pale ale which, the label claims, lies “somewhere between a lager and an ale” brewed with a blend of “aromatic, fruity” hops and lager malts. And I suppose that, given the previously mentioned mission statement to convert lager drinkers to real ale, this makes a certain amount of sense. But the result is a beer with a bit of an identity-crisis which, given the decent amount of choice generally on offer in most supermarkets, isn’t going to help it get past the ‘curiosity-satisfying’ purchase stage and turn it into a staple cellar-filler. It’s pleasant enough. And as the vast majority of the taste-testers who were filmed said, it’s “not bad”. But then, it’s not “great” either. Nobody on the TV show said “wow!” when they tried it, and neither did I…

The first thing I noticed, on sniffing the bottle-neck, is a rather pungent aroma of… well, I wasn’t really sure what, but it was something not entirely pleasant. The beer poured a very light golden colour with a frothy white head and luckily the aroma settled down and became more recognisably beer-like in the process. First impression on tasting was of a definite effervescence, a malty, biscuity flavour, a hint of sourness, a hint of hoppiness. After that, things got a little… flat. It was beery, definitely, but lacked the outright mega-hop hit of a good IPA (and I’ve had a few big IPA’s recently, so they’re still fresh in my mind) leaving it languishing rather in bland summer ale territory; it reminded me a little of the Theakston’s Lightfoot Bitter I tried a while back (which is ironic, seeing as the pair seem to have rather fallen out with Paul Theakston). The hop notes did develop towards the end of the glass after it had been breathing a while, but overall I’m afraid I was left with a sense of… yeah, “not bad”. Nice enough, but… so what?

Further Thoughts…

I could hazard a guess (without having seen episodes 2 and 3 yet) that, in an attempt to make their debut brew palatable to those legions of pre-conversion lager-drinkers out there, they could’ve dumbed it down to make it (literally) easier to swallow. But in that case, I’m rather afraid they’ve probably dumbed it down to the point of depriving it of a distinct character, something to make it stand out from the rest of the real-ale crowd. Which could either be chalked up as a failure or a success, depending on your point of view. And I rather think that – given the intention to establish this one as a supermarket-regular, commercial brand rather than a characterful (but perhaps, more commercially limited) Real Ale – Mssrs Morrissey and Fox would actually prefer their first beer to be described as a lager-like summer beer that’s easy enough to drink but won’t leave you feeling like you’ve tried something too new, or too distinct.

Let’s not forget, as well, that this is just their first brew and they’ve already announced plans to release two new ones in the near future. So perhaps with their next batch, having established themselves as a presence on the shelves of Tesco with their Blonde Ale, they might actually go for something a little more interesting and challenging.

To summarise: I, personally, wasn’t hugely impressed with Morrissey Fox Blonde Ale, but then I don’t think I, or any of the other Blog o’ Beer guys, or anyone who might get around to reading these tasting notes, will be the intended audience. And I’m not going to write these guys off just yet. They might not be doing anything quite as interesting as the likes of Meantime or Brewdog or any one of hundreds of other well-established, small, independent and/or micro-breweries, or at least not just yet. But they are prepared to use Morrissey’s celebrity status, Fox’s reputation as a chef and the production budget of a Channel 4 documentary show to promote the cause of real ale and real ale drinking… and that alone seems worth supporting.

So I reckon that even if you only buy one bottle of Morrissey Fox, just to give it a go, and then never go back again, you should at least do that. I’ve had my one, and I probably won’t be having another Blonde Ale in a bottle, but if I find myself in Marton cum Grafton in the near future then I’ll definitely nip into the Olde Punch Bowl to try a pint of the draught version, and to see what sort of new additions they’ve made to the range.

What the other beer bloggers are saying:

  • http://boakandbailey.com Bailey

    A few of the other beer bloggers seem to really rate this. We haven’t tried it yet, but it doesn’t sound terribly exciting even from the blurb on the bottle.

    I think quite a lot of UK microbreweries could do to sit down with that advertising chap from the TV show (or, in fact, any kind of marketing person) and get some frank advice on the importance of brand identity. A strong brand has really helped Meantime find a niche in the market, although decent beer also helps…

  • http://www.darrenturpin.me.uk Darren Turpin

    Hi Bailey – Yeah, that’s the point I was kinds groping towards… Meantime have a range of incredible beers to go with their interesting branding. And the likes of Brewdog are developing theirs along similar lines with their “fuck you if you don’t like it, go drink something else” message, which is refreshingly direct :)

    IMHO, every micro-brewer in the country probably ought to read a couple of books by a chap called Seth Godin: the first is ‘Purple Cow’, which talks about the need to be truly remarkable if you’re going to attract the sort of cult following that will turn your product into a must-have.

    The second is ‘The Dip’, which talks about the need to recognise the point at which the obstacles in your path demand a decision: is it time to cut your losses and move on to something else, or is it time to push through because you know you have something truly remarkable on your hands that’s worth the effort.

    And come to think of it, his next book, ‘Tribes’ should be a must-read as well (all about the importance of building a solid customer base from like-minded people who buy into your whole outlook and ethos, not just your introductory offers or low, low prices…)

    There’s so much I could blather on about when it comes to the meeting of beer and marketing, but time is short…

  • http://www.edash.wordpress.com Ed Ashby

    Tesco must reckon there isn’t any demand here as I haven’t seen any this side of the Irish Sea yet.

  • http://thebeerdiary.blogspot.com Tim

    I think that the bottled product is a different beer to the cask version. I think the bottles are probably brewed under licence somewhere else.
    I had a pint of this on Sat night at The Pontifract Castle in W1, and from Cask it is a very different beer. It’s has a cascade aroma and is deeply bitter for a blonde ale. Nothing like the bottled version. I would have the cask version again if I came across it. Apparently its a guest beer at Nicolsons pubs at the moment.

  • http://www.darrenturpin.me.uk Darren Turpin

    Hi Tim – That sounds much more impressive. I don’t think it’s made it over to my side of the Pennines on draught yet, but I’ll keep an eye out for it at the Bury Beer Festival at the weekend.

  • Richard Harries

    Well there’s no sign of it coming into Wales yet and at the prices they’re charging for food and drink at their pub I’m surprised they haven’t gone bust yet.

  • http://www.darrenturpin.me.uk Darren Turpin

    LOL :) I’ve not seen a menu, I have to admit, but I’ll bet the TV series will have had an inflationary effect on the cost of their bangers & mash… basic supply & demand there, I reckon :)

  • http://freakytrigger.co.uk/ft/2008/11/bottleneck-at-capel-curig/ CarsmileSteve

    I was wondering how they were intending to service a contract to provide tesco with half a million bottles over six months if they can only make three barrels a week…

    as i mention in my link there, the stuff we had at the focus group was pretty tasteless.

  • http://www.darrenturpin.me.uk Darren Turpin

    Hi Steve – Apologies for the delay in your comment appearing there… it was grabbed and held by Akismet for approval, for some reason (really not sure why…)

  • Dodgy

    Does anyone know who brews this blonde ale/lager like beer?? Is it all brewed in a small micro at t’ back of t’ pub? Must be on the go 24:7!!

    Would also love to know who created and controls the recipe. From home brew to micro to mass production isn’t just a question of increasing proportions??

    Is OK -but not as flavoursome/interesting as say Yellowhammer, Summer Lightning or Crop Circle.

    Brand identity is key I agree, but for most start ups I’m sure is not so easy without a built in celeb and contacts in high profile media.. and big budget… (could go on here).

    Methinks a clever marketing exercise to exploit celebrity to differentiate in a competitive market……..? Not sure I just said that!

    But -anything that encourages folk back into pubs drinking traditional ales has to be good??

  • http://www.darrenturpin.me.uk Darren Turpin

    Hi Dodgy -

    Well, I’m sure I read somewhere that there are three different breweries involved in mass-production (including Marstons? Did I remember that right?) but I’m guessing if you want a pint of the micro-brewed then you’d have to turn up at their place (and be prepared to shell out small fortune to eat there as well, by all accounts…)

    And I reckon they probably got advice from their indie-brewery mates down the road when it came to scaling up the quantities?

    You’re absolutely right about the celebrity exploitation angle, but then that was always going to be their competitive advantage – in the same way that if Ray Winstone opened up a brewery in the East End or Sean Connery started distilling whisky on Islay – it was always going to guarantee massive amounts of media attention, which is what got them the Tesco deal, clearly.

    But then, if they don’t shift half a million bottles per year (and once the TV series has faded from memory, the acid test will be how many regular drinkers go back to buy more, over and over again) then they’ll lose the supermarket deal. And if, by that point, they haven’t cleared their debts and can turn a profit from the pub, micro-brewery and local / online distribution (incidentally, have they even bothered with online distribution?) then presumably the venture will be on the rocks. Unless they can wangle a second TV series… Neil Morrissey’s Risky Export Adventure, anyone?

    And your final point is the key one – more beer drinkers is good for all the breweries of the UK, eventually…

  • Richard Harries

    Well Morrissey has failed once with a pub in west Wales. He bought a local in Laugharne because of Dylan Thomas’s boathouse being there! He didn’t realise that just become Dylan Thomas was a piss head from Swansea who laxed lyrical about ale(much loved by Americans-ignored by Welshmen), didn’t mean everyone else was. Has the series now finished?

  • http://www.darrenturpin.me.uk Darren Turpin

    Cheers for that, Richard! My missus remembered something about a pub in Wales, but neither of us were sure of the details. At least this time around him and Fox have got the TV deal to give them a leg-up. And yeah, the series is over, although it’ll probably start repeating on cable before too long.

  • http://www.edash.wordpress.com Ed Ashby

    And there’s a book as well, surprisingly called Morrissey’s Perfect Pint.

  • http://www.darrenturpin.me.uk Darren Turpin

    Yeah, Jo got me a copy of that from the book club at work. Haven’t had a chance to give it a go yet.

  • http://www.edash.wordpress.com Ed Ashby

    The series is currently being repeated this week on Channel 4, in the early hours.

  • george ingleby

    i had a excellent pint in the BIRBECK TV E10 TODAY 30/12/08

  • http://hotmail kenneth baker

    i had an excellent pnit in indigo alley and scarborough arms 5/6/2009

  • kenneth

    i had excelent pint of morrissy fox blonde in the indigo scarborough 18/062009

  • Alwyn Jones

    Morrisey came to Wales and took the piss. Disaster after disaster, apparently conning the locals. Left a sour and bitter taste in Laugharne. Cheers as he left hopefully never to return.

  • http://www.darrenturpin.me.uk Darren Turpin

    Apparently it was annoying the locals that did for their North Yorkshire venture as well. They didn’t like the price hikes so they took their business off to the next village and then when all the TV fuss died down so did the takings… or so I heard.